Enroll

Concern and Controversy: Teaching the First World War

"Those who don't know history are destined to repeat it." - Edmund Burke

With the hundredth anniversary of its outbreak this year, the First World War looms over the horizon like a lumbering giant of educational controversy.

The UK's always outspoken education secretary Michael Gove has stirred another of his monthly controversies by writing on the subject. Suggesting that our view of the war has been warped by the influence of left-wing academics and television producers, he has created a backlash of anger and ridicule while friends and allies leap to his defence. It's a debate that will change few opinions, but has filled some entertaining column inches.

With or without Gove this was likely to become a touchy subject. It would be wrong not to teach such a significant event in its centennial year, but we need to think more carefully than ever about how to handle it.

Floundering in Flanders

It's not hard to understand why an event that killed millions still stirs high emotions. A terrible, gruelling conflict whose most famous element was the mud and blood shed in northern France, everyone involved wants to honour the lives lost. But for different people that means very different things.

For those who share Gove's view, it is an insult to the fallen not to recognise the nobility of their sacrifice and the justice of their cause. They view the allied role in the war as a just one, defending against German aggression. To say otherwise belittles our loss.

For others - and I freely admit to sharing this view - there was no nobility or justice in this war. Millions of ordinary people died for the sake of national pride and the political games of those in power. To say otherwise belittles our loss.

With such polarised opinions, how can we do justice to the subject in schools?

Facing the past with courage

The answer, or course, is to treat pupils like intelligent human beings capable of forming their own opinions. None of us can completely eradicate our views from the way that we teach a subject, but we can endeavour to teach both sides and to let pupils make up their own minds. It's a way of teaching the skills as well as the facts of history, letting them explore the opportunities and the challenges of interpretation.

We should not be afraid to teach a topic because it is controversial, or to look that controversy in the eye. We are lucky that, unlike those young men of a century ago, we do not have to muster the courage to march into the artillery-blasted hell of no-man's land, or to face imprisonment or even death for refusing to fight. We can at least have the courage to discuss their fate and the way that people of all persuasions feel about it today.

 

Image by Toronto History via Flickr creative commons

Andrew Knighton

About Andrew Knighton

I'm a writer and ex-teacher. You can find more of my writing on education at: http://www.degreediary.com/bloggers/27 I also have a blog on reading and writing: https://andrewknighton.wordpress.com/

Andrew Knighton

Top Posts | Lesson Plans & Activities

Swim4Sadna Is Truly an Inspiring Journey

This story of one Jewish mother’s courageous mission to help others is indeed inspiring. It is about British-born Vivienne Glaser’s decision to help a special education center in need of money and resources. She decided that it was time to give something back to a school which has alrea ... ...

5 Easy Tips for Making Lesson Plans Great

Teachers come in all shapes and sizes, and the methods they use vary greatly. There are some that plan meticulously, and others that prefer to fly by the seat of their pants. I believe that a mixture of both is the best way to a smooth, stress-free lesson. Here are a few tips:A good lesso ... ...

Building Better Reading Habits

There are some things that never go out of style or become obsolete, and one of these things is reading. Needless to say, reading is not only a practical part of life but also a means to escape the pressures we encounter on a daily basis.The medium we use for reading may have evolved over the years ...

Is Your K-6 Child Struggling with Science?

Searching for an innovative but fun method to maintain your child's attention for science? Luckily, science has the potential to become one of the most involved subjects, depending on how it is taught. If your child is struggling to enjoy science in school, you can try a few fun projects at hom ... ...

Schools Experiment with Tech Blend

The Grant Beacon Middle School in Denver has adopted a new teaching procedure for its students. Children studying there get to spend a lot of time in a blended learning scenario. They are allowed to use Chromebooks to access digital curricula and are also offered traditional classroom education tha ...

Fun & Easy Valentine Crafts for Kids

With Valentine's Day quickly approaching, many teachers will be on the look out for crafts their students can make to celebrate the holiday. Unfortunately for teachers, holidays can also mean room parties, unfocused students, and the pressure to send cute and creative gifts home with students. ... ...

An Inspiring Youth Rises from Orem

The youth is the future. That’s definitely true. And it is only right to educate the young people properly and encourage them to learn new things; and that is what this inspiring young lad from Orem tried to point out.He is not your average 15-year old for he is a rising specialist in compute ... ...